Choosing a wireless charging solution (1): communication reliability
- # Selection
- # Communication
Note: Translated from the Chinese original.
Compared with conventional wired charging, wireless charging needs no plugging, involves no physical contact, can improve safety, costs less to maintain and copes better with harsh environments. For mid- and high-power industrial applications this is now widely accepted. In practice, however, the reliability of wireless charging solutions varies widely between brands. Many industrial customers have run into trouble and taken on significant after-sales maintenance costs, and it usually comes down to one symptom: the device often fails to charge. There are several causes. So which aspects of a wireless charging solution should you look at during selection to avoid these pitfalls? We will discuss this in three parts.
This part covers the first factor in choosing a wireless charging solution:
- Communication reliability
The transmitter and receiver of a wireless charging system do not touch. Establishing and stopping charging, adjusting the output, safety protection, and reporting and handling faults all require wireless communication between the two sides. Most wireless charging solutions on the market use an add-on 2.4 GHz module for this. Countries and regions regulate radio bands differently, and 2.4 GHz is the most widely used globally available ISM band. It carries Wi-Fi, Bluetooth and other protocols, and it is also the most common band for out-of-band communication in wireless charging solutions. Precisely because it is so widely used, it is easily disturbed in complex environments and may in turn interfere with other 2.4 GHz devices. Typically, where there are many Wi-Fi and Bluetooth devices around the charger, a solution using 2.4 GHz out-of-band communication is easily disrupted, so it fails to start charging or drops out mid-charge. The problem is worse where some vendors use low-performance 2.4 GHz chips to cut costs.
Tseetech’s wireless charging solutions below 300 W use carrier-based in-band communication. Carrier communication is low-cost, stable and less prone to interference. Put simply, the transmitter and receiver coils both exchange data and transfer power, which avoids the environmental interference that affects 2.4 GHz links and keeps charging reliable.
For higher-power wireless power supply applications that need fast start-up and see frequent load steps, carrier communication loses some of its advantage. Tseetech also offers wireless charging solutions based on 2.4 GHz communication. To keep the link reliable, these combine a carefully selected 2.4 GHz chip with our own frequency-hopping software algorithm that responds to interference, so communication stays stable.