Skip to content
Tseetech

In-band or out-of-band communication in wireless power: how to choose?

  • # Communication

Note: Translated from the Chinese original.

By Gangming Li

In a complete wireless power transfer (WPT) system, the transmitter and receiver must communicate, and the link must stay stable and reliable from the start of power transfer to the end. During transfer, the transmitter needs to know accurately how much power the receiver is getting so it can run closed-loop power control. Other information also has to pass between the two sides, such as the receiver’s charging state, authentication between transmitter and receiver, and device information — all of which matter for commercializing and standardizing wireless charging. A stable communication system also improves the user experience, transfer safety and efficiency, and makes new applications possible. So far, WPT systems mainly use two kinds of communication: in-band and out-of-band.

  1. In-band communication

Wireless charging systems based on the widely used Qi standard communicate in-band: the signal is carried on the power signal itself. In Qi, the receiver talks to the transmitter using amplitude shift keying (ASK), which can be implemented in two ways: resistive modulation, shown in Figure 1(a), and capacitive modulation, shown in Figure 1(b). The receiver switches a transistor according to the data sequence, changing its impedance. Through the mutual inductance between the coils, the transmitter coil’s voltage and current change accordingly, so the transmitter only needs to demodulate the amplitude of the coil voltage or current to recover the signal. In the other direction, the transmitter talks to the receiver using frequency shift keying (FSK): it modulates the data onto the power signal by changing the frequency of the inverter drive signal, and the receiver recovers the data by detecting changes in the frequency of the receiver coil voltage or current.

In-band communication is simple, low-cost and easy to implement, but it has limitations. It supports only one-to-one communication, and changes in the relative position of transmitter and receiver affect signal quality and therefore stability. A robust demodulation circuit is thus a key part of the system design when this method is used.

a) Resistive modulation

b) Capacitive modulation

Figure 1: ASK communication modulation methods in the Qi standard

  1. Out-of-band communication

Out-of-band communication keeps the data exchanged between transmitter and receiver completely independent of power transfer. This lets us use off-the-shelf communication solutions for fast two-way communication between the two sides and a better user experience. Common out-of-band options include Bluetooth, Zigbee and near field communication (NFC); wireless charging systems today mainly use Bluetooth or 2.4 GHz radio. The AirFuel Alliance uses Bluetooth Low Energy, which easily supports one-to-many communication, works over longer distances and is less prone to interference. Compared with in-band communication, however, it is more complex and costs more. When evaluating a solution, out-of-band communication suits applications with medium to long transfer distances and one-to-many charging.

Make your fleet charge itself

Tell us your application, power and gap — an engineer will reply with a recommendation within one business day.