Skip to content
Tseetech

Through-surface chargers and MagSafe iPhones: charging compatibility

  • # Consumer electronics
  • # Foreign object detection

Note: Compatibility here means measured charging behaviour, not MagSafe certification.

In our article of 21 September 2021, we described how the largest furniture maker is bringing through-surface charging into its products. There is a tricky question most people are not aware of:

Is through-surface charging compatible with Apple MagSafe?

You might assume the answer is obviously yes, since Apple says every iPhone since the iPhone 8 is Qi-compatible. But search online for iPhone 12 compatibility with Qi-certified chargers and you will find many reports of Qi chargers that cannot charge the iPhone 12 series. The cause is MagSafe.

For the MagSafe experience, Apple placed magnets around the receiver coil inside the phone. A MagSafe charger attaches precisely to the phone and concentrates its magnetic field on the phone’s receiver area. Some Qi chargers, by contrast, leak magnetic field onto these magnets and heat them. In some of these chargers, the magnets trigger foreign object detection and charging stops. Others loosen the FOD threshold so that charging continues, but the heated magnets then make the phone throttle its charging speed. The battery level can even fall over time while the screen still shows the charging icon.

This gives a poor experience to anyone charging an iPhone 12, or the upcoming iPhone 13, without a MagSafe charger. Because through-surface chargers use larger transmitter coils, they are particularly prone to leaking field onto the magnets in the iPhone. We do not know whether the furniture maker has solved this in its newly announced through-surface charger; consumer feedback after launch will tell.

As a pioneer of through-surface charging, Tseetech has analysed the MagSafe compatibility problem in depth and developed its own solution. Our QB06 and QB21 charge the iPhone 12 series from 0% to 100% in about the same time as Apple’s original 15 W MagSafe charger. Taking the iPhone 12 Pro as an example, published tests give these charging times:

Apple iPhone 12 Pro MagSafe pad wireless charging speed

176 minutes (2 hours and 56 minutes)

The MagSafe charger and 20 W adapter bundle costs nearly 60 USD.

https://www.phonearena.com/news/apple-iphone-12-pro-magsafe-vs-20w-vs-18w-vs-5w-charging-speeds_id128110

So with Apple’s 60 USD bundle, an iPhone 12 Pro charges from 0% to 100% in about 3 hours.

Below is the performance of Tseetech’s QB21 through-surface charger. Through a 45 mm surface, the iPhone 12 Pro charges from 0% to 40% in one hour and fully within 3 hours.

QB21 through-surface charging of an iPhone 12 Pro Max: battery level and screen temperature
Charging time (h:mm) Battery level (%) Screen temp. (°C)
0:00 0 25.6
0:30 20 34.4
1:00 40 37.0
1:30 59 37.8
2:00 76 36.5
2:30 91 35.9
3:00 100 31.6

A MagSafe charger is a personal accessory, which makes it hard to build into furniture. Tseetech’s through-surface charger reaches about the same charging speed as Apple’s 15 W MagSafe charger while staying hidden under the surface, so furniture makers can offer charging spots wherever they are needed. Contact us to discuss your project.

Make your fleet charge itself

Tell us your application, power and gap — an engineer will reply with a recommendation within one business day.